HomeMy WebLinkAbout11092005 Historic Preservation Minutes
lJ!.IB)[ ql!M ~upflOM n!lS SUM :)qs P:)lOU :mAO)[ "UO!lllU!WOU :)qllOJ Al!J :)ql JO ~UPI:mq :)ql ~u!lS:)nb:)l
SUM OdHS "l! lloddns pUll pll:)qll O~ PfI\OM :)qs lnq q:ll:)llS II :)q Ol p:)lll:)ddll UO!lllU!WOU :)ql
P:)llllS pllq UOSUOlUY lllql pUll uO!lll:l!Iddll :)ql U! :)U!I :)W!l pUll 'UO!llllU:)Wn:lOP 'SOlOqd :)ql :)pnpU! Ol
lUllllOdW! SUMl! P:)llllS :)qS 'l:)lS!3a~ :lpOlSm IllUO!lll N :)qllOJ UO!lllU!WOU :)ql ~U!Plll~:)l :)~lllOq:lUV
U! :):lYJO UO!lllAl:)S:)ld :lpOlSm :)llllS :)qllll UOSUOlUV Of ql!M l:)W pllq :)qs P:)llllS :lllAO)[
}f.llld u3QoH
':)WOH :):r] :)ss:)f :)qllOJ s:)nss! UO!l~O:l:)l uo
ps:) A l:)~llUllW Al!J lUlllS!SSY :)ql pUlll:)JllqS lOAllW ql!M "'{lOM Ol p:)nU!lUO:l :)q P:)llllS UUllMS
3lBpdn SUO!SS3S }f.loM. UO!lB.lOlS3113woH 33'l3SS3f
SUO!lBlU3S3.1d ", Slu3w33unouuy 'sl.IOd311.13QlO
"~U!l:):)W lsuI :)ql :):lU!S s:)!l!A!l:lll UO!lllAl:)S:)ld :lpOlSm M:)U ou P:)llllS UMOlg
l.IOd311 UO!lB.llS!U!Wpy AlD
P:)Sn:lX:) - n:)MO"}l s:)Wllf
::)l:)M lu:)sqy
lUlllS!SSY ~U!UUllId 'zu:)ID llUUOa
l:)UUllId 'UMOlg WIO:lfllW
pUll ~UO!SS!wwoJ :)ql JO WnJonb II 3u!spdwo:l
l:)~U!ll:)H-l:)",{IllM. llpllq:l!W
l:)qnH UOUUllqS UUllMS wOl
"'{llld :)P:)Ill A l:)lU:)dll!J 3:)lD
pUll '~U!P!s:)ld l!llqJ-:lllAO)[ UOUUllqS :lU:)S:)ld :)l:)M :)l:)ql
lIB;) IIOll
"~llLJ :)ql Ol :):lUll!~:)nY JO :)~P:)Id :)ql P:)I l:)lU:)dll!J
AUOW3.13J jU!u3dO
':lllAO)[ UOUUllqS 'l!llqJ Aq 'w'd vt:9 llll:)plO Ol P:)Ifll:l
SUM UO!SS!WWOJ UO!lllAl:)S:lld :lpOlSm PlllM:)S :)ql JO ~U!l:):)W lll~:ll ~OOZ '6 l:)qW:)AO N :)ql
.I3p.lO Ol IIBJ
8rl aJivd '[ alUn[oA
samu!y,{ UO!SS!lUlUO:J uO!JvtUasa,/d :J!'/oJS!H
mOL '6 '/aqlUatloN
V1fsvfV 'p,/VM.asJo N!:J
City of Seward, Alaska
November 9,2005
Historic Preservation Commission Minutes
Volume 1, Page 259
Sturdy, Parks and Recreation Director on what involvement the City felt the SHPO office would
have in the restoration of the park ifit were to be placed on the register.
Citizen Comments on Agenda Items Not Scheduled For Public Hearing
Carol Griswold, inside the City. Stated she had provided a hand out on the Seward Heritage
Tree Program. She noted the intent of the program was to recognize significant trees and plants in
our area.
Lynn Hohl, inside the City. She informed the Commission the Friends of State Parks planned a
meeting for January 18, 2005 at Resurrect Art Coffee House.
Approval of Agenda
Motion (Walker-Hettinger/Swann)
Approve the Agenda
Motion Passed
Unanimous Consent
Public Hearing - None
Unfinished Business
Resolution 2005-02, statement of position regarding the proposed Vacation of
Washington Street
Chair Kovac stated she was no longer employed as a seasonal worker for the Park Service
and therefore no longer had the appearance of a conflict of interest. The Commission agreed and she
remained as the Chair.
Commissioner Huber declared a conflict of interest as an employee of the Park Service and
removed herself from the dais.
Brown stated that at the October Historic Preservation meeting the Commission had heard
public comment and discussed the proposed vacation of Washington Street. He noted issue before
the Commission was the historic impact of the proposed vacation of Washington Street not the
design of the proposed building or other building around the area. He reviewed the location of the
proposed vacation.
Motion (Swann/Carpenter)
Approve Resolution 2005-02
Motion (Walker-Hettinger/Swann)
Amend Resolution 2005-02, fifth Whereas,
add "and historic views" following
transportation grid.
p3p03m8 S8 ZO~SOOZ 00!JDlos31I 00 3JO A
.I3~om3H-.I3"118M '008AlS :oN
38AO)l '.I3J03d.I8:J "'I.lUd :S3 A
P3SS8d 00!J0J\I
"l:;)lU:;)q PlnoM suuld :;)lpJo sluo'3 :;)l{l uO!lnlos:;)l:;)lp '3U!PU:;)UlU
Aq lUlll P:;)lUlS :JUAO)l "UUld :J!'3:;)lUllS :;)l{llO uuld :;)A!SU:;)l{:;)ldlUO;) :;)lp lO uuld UOnUAl:;)s:;)ld :J!lOlS!H :;)l{l
JO slUo'3 :;)l{ll:;):;)lU lOU P!P UOnU:JUA p:;)SodOld :;)lp lUlp p:;)w:;):Juo:J AJ:;)A SUM :;)l{S lUl{l P:;)lOU :JUAO)l
"l:;):;)llS
uQl'3U!l{SU M.lsnf Ull1p :;)lOlU SUM UJ:;)llud p!J'a :;)lp lUlp ~lUlS:;)H "UOnU:JUA:;)lp p:;)lloddns UUllMS
"'30!pnnq :;)l{ljO S:;)IDlU:;)J :;)AH:;)lW:;)lU! OlU! W:;)llud p!J'a :;)l{l
SS:;)lpPU PITIO:J l:;)lU:;);) H:;)M<YJ Amy;[ :;)l{l P:;)lUlS PUll :;):J!Al:;)S )[lUd :;)l{l P:;)lOU l:;)'3U!ll:;)H-l:;))[IUM.
"UUld :J!'iJ:;)lUllS :;)lp lO UUld :;)A!SU:;)l{:;)ldlUO;) 'UUld UO!lUAl:;)S:;)ld
:J!lOJS!H :;)lp JO slUo'3 :;)lp l:;):;)lU lOU PW UO!lU:JUA P:;)SOdOld :;)lp lUlp P:;)lOU :;)l{S "l:;):;)llS uol'iJO!l{SU M. lUOl]
M:;)!A :;)l{l '3U!U!UlU!UlU p:;)lloddns :;)l{S "p!J'a UO!lUllodSUUll :;)l{l JO :;):JUU:Jy!u'3!S :J!lOlS!l{ P:;)'3p:;)IMOU)[:JU
:;)lp UO UO!S!:J;)P l;)l{ p:;)suq ;)l{S "l:;);)llS uol'iJU!l{SUM. JO UO!lU:JUA ;)l{lllOddns Ol :;){qU lOU SUM :;)l{S
P:;)lUlS :;)l{S ":;)l!SUMOl lUU!'3!lO :;)lpJO p!J'a :J!lOlS!l{:;)lp p:;)lloddns AI'3UOllS )[lUd l;)UO!SS!lUlUO;)
"3S0ddo "S"
pP8 p08 AJ:3A!J38 JOO S30p 3AOm3.1 '1 00!J33S
~P3J838A 3q OJ 3.13Al J33.1JS 00JDII!qs8M
ji 3AOm3.1 'S83.13qM qJX!S ~3soddo
OJ "s" pP8 p08 AI3A!J38 JOO S30p 3AOm3.1
'SU3.l3q,\\ qtJ!.!f 'zo-sooz 00!JDlos31I p03mV
(008AlSI'I.l8d) 00!J0J\I
SOOm!080[l
p31!8.!f 00!J0J\I
"'3U!pnnq :;)l{l OlU! p:;)u'3!S:;)P :;)q lOU AUlU lO AUlU lUl{M
UO p:;)suq:;)q OllOU SUM UO!S!:J:;)P:;)lp P:;)lUlS:;)H "'3U!pnnq :;)l{ljO u'3!S:;)P :;)l{l uo lOU l:;):;)llS uol'iJU!l{SUM.
JO UO!lU:JUA :;)lp UO SUM UOnnlos:;)l ;)lp JO sn:JoJ :;)lp lUlp UO!SS!lUlUO;) :;)lp P:;)PU!lU:;)ll:;)lU:;)dm;)
"Sl:;):;)llS :;)S:;)lp lUOl] SM:;)!A :;)lp '3U!U!UlUlUlU p:;)lloddns AI'3UOllS PUll lU:;)lUlUO:J :Juqnd lUl{l
P:;)lOU :;)l{S ":;)nU:;)AV l{llnod PUUl:;):;)llS uol'iJU!l{SUM. lUOl] SM:;)!A :;)l{l P:;)lUlS l:;)'3U!ll:;)H-l:;))[IUM.
"UO!lOlU :;)l{l Aq P:;)l:J:;)lOld :;)q Ol
:;)J:;)M SM:;)!A lUl{M JO UOHU:J!JllUP p:;)lS:;)nOOl :;)l{ SM:;)!A :J!lOJS!l{ :;)lp JSUlU'3u AI'iJUOllS :;))[OdS UUllMS
",J:;):;)llS uol'iJU!l{SU M. suuds lUlp 4m:>uJ ~lp JO UO!S!:>:;)p
:;)l{l OlU! p:;)pnpU! :;)q SM:;)!A :J!lOlS!l{ pOll w:;)llud p!J'a :;)l{lluql SAUM lUl:;)A:;)S P:;)SOdOld APU:;)lIU suq
UlU:;)l u'3!S:;)P :;)l{l" P:;)lUlS PUll :;):J!Al;)S )[lUd :;)lpJO MOy;[JJ:;)f P:;)lOU ;)l{S "l{!nq;)q Ol P:;)UUllld SUM l:;)lU:;);)
H:;)MO'I Amy;[ P:;)SOdOld :;)l{l :;)l;)l{M M:;)!A :J!lOlS!l{ lU:;)lJn:J :;)lp p:;)lloddns l:;)'3U!ll:;)H-l:;))[lUM.
09l al1vc/ '[ awn/oA
sa/null'{ uOlsslwwo:J uOl/vMasa.Jc/ :Jl.Jo/slH
mOl '6.JaqwatloN
VJfsvlV 'p.JVM.asJo NO
City of Seward, Alaska
November 9, 2005
Historic Preservation Commission Minutes
Volume 1, Page 261
Motion Passed
Yes: Park, Carpenter, Kovac
No: Swann, Walker-Hettinger
Commissioners Huber returned to the dais
New Business
Discussion regarding the creation of a Seward register of significant local trees
and plants
Kovac noted that Griswold had spoken earlier about the recognition of the local historic trees
and plants. She stated while doing the research on the Hoben Park she had been struck by the lack of
the historic plants and trees that had been in the park. Kovac requested input from the Commission
on the idea of developing an inventory similar to the Seward Historical Site Inventory.
In response to Walker-Hettinger, Kovac stated the inventory was just a listing and provided
no regulatory or protective action of the trees or plants.
Brown and Kovac both thanked Griswold for her time and research of the local plants and
trees.
Swann voiced strong support for the inventory and felt it was a very good place to start to
develop a program that could in the future be enhanced to further recognize the importance of the
historic trees and plants in Seward.
The Commission felt the project was suited for a work session.
Discussion of City owned artifacts recovered during the construction of the
Alaska Sealife Center
Kovac noted that when the Alaska Sealife Center was constructed there was archeological
work done. She noted that work was done on both City and State lands. The City was not interested
in the artifacts. The Park Service has stored and had custody of the artifacts for the last 10 years and
now has requested that a permanent home be found. Chugach Museum has requested that the City
gift their portion of these artifacts to the museum for further study and secure housing. The City has
agreed that the City portion of the artifacts should be gifted to the Chugach Museum. The State
portion of the artifacts was currently being worked through the process. It was hoped that the State
would also gift their portion to the museum, keeping the artifact collection all together.
Informational Items - (No action required) None
(~
l!Ul{;)
:mAO)l UOUtlUl{S
[
r
, " ' ,0, "7, r..".",
/" ,. '",,' /f/f ..' ".~
/"
- I
I
.t~U~U'tl.,
t""-;" \.1 -!o ..;qt.'!'
, ~",\J .. .' ::; J'#
~'#" ~ ..%..:.eor,. .... ,,{~ "'.,)~.....
$-4f,,':.;i'. ~ 2;"';;...~1Sl .~.
::..11 "~e_ ~
.. .. -. '",
... ----- _ Eie,
: .. i ~r;rs i.:
~ . ~v ~ . Q
.. \. : Ik't
~ ~o -+- ~: :
~ -'.~ r:,''- ~
., o~""(""'"O -,"0 ..' f.) ..
., -.""t:::I Q'O.. '" :'II.
..~ p.; ........ ..' ~-.; ....
......,,,./11;;;$ ...(()~~~;))
111'''II~''''
lutllS!SSY ilu!UtlUId
ZU:lID UUUO<fI
/~l /J , ~'-'K
.1/ , 'tY/.J 1
---:,,--l_f\I:.J - ^ -~ \.."., - Y-.- ~ -~'\"-_ -_-_~___
J
'urd Ot:L lU p:lwnofpu SUM ~U!l:l:lW :ltU.
"UtlUMS ld:l:>X:l :lJqUI!UAU :ll:lM Sl:lUO!SS!WWO;) ny 'UO!SS:lS ){lOM U lOJ WOOl
:l:>U:ll:lJUO:> Sl!UlSdn 'oo:n lU 900(; 't A.llmuu[ l:lS UO!SS!WWO;) :ll{l UO!ssn:>S!P U ~U!A\Onod
'P:lfOld SluuId puu
S:l:lll Iu:>oI lUU:>Y~!S :ll{llOJ UO!SS:lS ){lOM U l:lS UO!SS!WWO;) :ll{llUl{l P:llS:lil~ns .Ialoawu:)
- sloawwo:) soaZ!lD Ol asoodsal{ oOnU.llS!O!WPV 1f1 OO!SS!wwo:)
'ls:lnb:ll UO!lU:>UA AUM-JO-l~!l p:lSOdOld :ll{l UO
UO!lllpU:lWWQ:>:ll p:lllO:> :ll{l SUM lPJ :ll{S lUl{M lOJ UO!SS!WWO;) :ll{l p:l){UUl{l :ll{S 'uoos plUMlOJ :lAOW
PJllOM l:>:lfOld :ll{llUl{l p:ldOl{ :ll{S OS U09~0:>;ll1O ~~OIUlU:> AUU lnOl{l!A\ P:lAOllS:lP U:l:lq APU:llIU PUll
Al!;) :ll{lo! SlUUId puu S:l:lll :>!lOlSN :ll{l JO AUUW lUl{l P:llQU :ll{S "UO!SS:lS ){lOM :ll{llOJ :llllp U p:llS:lnb:ll
puu P:lfOld :ll{ll{l!A\ dpl{ Ol p:ll:l:llunIoA :ll{S 'P:lfOld SlUUId puu S:l:lll JU:>OI lUU:>Y~!S JO l:llS!~:ll
plUM:lS :ll{l U! lS:ll:llU! :ll{llOJ UO!SS!WWO;) :ll{l p:l){UUl{l 'Al!;) :ll{l :lP!SU! 'PI0MS!.I~ 10.lU:)
Sloawwo:) soazm:)
'P:lfOld ){lUd U:lqoH :ll{l UO llOJJ:l puu :lW9 l:ll{ 10J :>UAO)l p:l){UUl{l.laloawu:)
Sloawwo:) OO!SS!WWO;)
Z9Z aiJvc/ .[ aUlnloA
sajnUW'l U01ss1UlUlOJ UOUVtUasa.lc/ :J1.10/s1H
moz '6.1aqUlaAoN
IDfsvlV 'p.lVMas!o ND